The three different kinds of responses Stewart and Tait received for their book, are identical to the ones my book "The imagined conflict" from 2021 has received in the eight or so reviews that have been published. Therefore I found comfort in reading it and reproducing it here. So little has changed in 150 years!
Stewart and Tait wrote: "As a preface to our Second Edition, we cannot do better than record the experience derived from our first. It is indeed gratifying to find a wonderful want of unanimity among the critics who assail us, and it is probably owing to this cause that we have been able to preserve a kind of kinetic stability, just as a man does in consequence of being equally belaboured on all sides by the myriad petty impacts of little particles of air.